Sha'i nyes dmigs mdor bsdus/Full text
From Bodhicitta
Texts/Sha'i nyes dmigs mdor bsdus/Full text
FULL TEXT
Description
Shardza spends the bulk of his work criticizing meat. He calls meat "nauseating" and argues at length that eating it is sinful and leads to birth in hell. But then, on the final page of his treatise, Shardza abruptly reverses his position and claims that people must eat meat. Without it, he claims, the body will become weak, feeble, and, crucially, unable to practice religion. And practicing religion is a rare opportunity, available only when one achieves a human birth with all of the freedoms and riches intact. But Shardza's advocacy of meat eating does not negate his earlier concerns.
Instead, he is claiming that people should eat meat despite the fact that it is sinful. Further, he proposes that, in order to minimize the negative karma of meat eating, people should eat "suitable" meat. But what kind of meat is suitable? To this Shardza gives two examples: the meat of animals that have died naturally and meat purchased in a market. The first involves no act of killing, so is karmically pure. Shardza himself followed just such a diet, eating only the meat of animals that died naturally. Meat purchased in the market is more problematic, and Shardza clearly sees it as an inferior option. But he does include it, seeming to reflect the idea that meat purchased in the market is more distant from the act of killing than when someone either personally kills the animal or specifically asks someone else to do it for them. (Source: Barstow, The Faults of Meat, 237)
| Reference | sha'i nyes dmigs mdor bsdus [ཤའི་ཉེས་དམིགས་མདོར་བསྡུས།]. [A Brief Account of the Faults of Eating Meat]. |
|---|---|
| People | Shardza Tashi Gyaltsen |